Do you all agree that a high KDR comes from playing lower skilled players?
Yes and no, I think it depends on how many kills, hours played, ect. Eventually you will play against the good and bad. Unless your entire game play is all about leaving and joining games looking for the specific one you want.
Okay. So, my premise was that the better quality player you play against when YOU are a good player, the closer you will be to a 1.0 KDR. As you go pubbing more, your KDR creeps up from that level.
The problem with even THAT is that a less skilled player can ALSO have a 1.0 KDR!
So, I'm trying to get us to discuss a way we can look at this, or bring in ideas from some other game that's already done it.
What if AAV implemented a match making service that followed Microsoft's trueskill? Seems like it covers a lot of ground on this topic already.
I'll touch on the KDR thing. I think that is one of the quickest ways to assume skill.
For instance
If you are in the top 1% - 5% of the game.
How often are you going to play with people at the same level as you. You aren't. Most of the time you will be playing with less skilled players, which is only going to increase your KDR.
Even if you have players as skilled as you in the server. Depending on the game play, you will still pick off all the usual players until you have to face off the same skilled player as yourself.
I'm interested in your assessment there, Hyperlite. Are you saying that picking off the low skilled players results in a high KDR that DOESN'T reflect skill, or does? Your choice of the word 'assume' can have a couple of connotations, so I'm trying to clarify.
It seems to me the only time skill is actually tested is against tough opponents, ergo the KDR starts to stray AWAY from a skill assessment metric, since low skill players virtually walk right into your crosshairs (compared to a tougher opponent.)
______
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
What if you're on the top of the food chain and everyone else is less skilled than you though? - Maybe that's why the hawkeyes, silvers and goldens stack up, thats why after thousand and thousands of kills the KDR is still high, thats why probably after hundreds of scrims and tournaments games the KDR isnt affected still. I don't know
Do you all agree that a high KDR comes from playing lower skilled players?
Yes, it definitely can. I'd still say though, that those folks on that KDR top list are still really good players, regardless of who they're playing against. The community is so kick/ban heavy, you can't possibly go 25-5 in servers for too long w/o getting banned in private servers.
But one thing i've found...especially in a FLO server..for every high skilled player, there are 8 other low skilled players to be killed. Definitely could still pull a 1.5+ in a FLO w/ good players. But BDX on the other hand, the odds of running into that high skilled player increase
I used the word assume bacause there are people out there that strive for K/D only and play that way. A high kdr tends to reflect skill in most instances.
Im just saying like Arkeiro said. If you are at the top of the food chain then your k/d is only going up. Doesnt matter how many other skilled players are in the server. You will pick off the easy ones until you have to engage with someone as skilled as you and then if you die, your k/d isnt going to change much. You've already killed all the bottom fraggers.
Yeah we are. There are a number of these services that natively integrate with UE4 that we would have to code by hand in UE3, and trueskill is one of them. Others, like Gamelift to manage server numbers and player backfill, will also be part of AAV.
Yeah we are. There are a number of these services that natively integrate with UE4 that we would have to code by hand in UE3, and trueskill is one of them. Others, like Gamelift to manage server numbers and player backfill, will also be part of AAV.
Hopefully that's in a completely different game mode...dare I say, a competitive/ranked game mode. The queue times may be very long unless the playerbase is much larger than it is now.
Also, I noticed there is no average damage dealt per round. I think that would also be good to add as an indicator of skill.
Some type of metric of KDR and damage would be where I would start for a toplist.
Most certainly! As K/D ratio is a statistical representation used to measure how good you are ,the KDR or ADR (average Damage per Round as in csgo) also FPR (avg. Frags per round) is used to represent how useful you are for the team.
If you're interested in establishing skill rankings, you're gonna have to have some mathematical equation involving more than just one variable like KD.. the more complicated the more accurate.
We have added a Top Players List to the AAStats home page. The list can be sorted by any of the stats columns (Kills, K/D Ratio, Exp Points, Matches Won, Win Pct, and Hours). When the list is sorted by K/D Ratio or Win Pct, only players with 100 or more completed matches are included:
Still planned for the Top Players List is a search field so you can find specific players on the list.
We have also made some changes in the Player Stats page. The General Statistics section has been rearranged somewhat, and some new stats for Experience Points, Matches Lost, Match Win Percentage, Kills per Match, Points per Match, Points per Round, and Favorite Map have been added:
Since we received some negative feed back about the readability of the blue background and table cell borders we are trying out some alternative looks on the Player Stats page.
Thanks for the update but I'm hoping to give you some constructive feedback here.
Are you able to get information on how much average damage someone does per round
The Toplist - Not the direction I would have gone but it is an option. For me I would think the Toplist would have some type of K/D and Damage ratio metric.
Top Kills - I would remove the unoffical leaderboard if you keep with the current format of Toplist because you can now sort
Remove takedowns as I dont think it is of importance
Remove Dev Kills - I dont see any value in parsing that info
Highest round score - I look at those numbers and I'm confused as to if that is match score or if it is really per round score.
Secures - I dont see the value in parsing that info
Favorite map - I dont know if I would say "favorite map", I would probably change that to "most Played map"
On a side note:
The player with a 5.71 K/D is either cheating or found a way to manipulate the info being parsed. The guy is averaging 16 kills a minute
Comments
What if AAV implemented a match making service that followed Microsoft's trueskill? Seems like it covers a lot of ground on this topic already.
https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2018/03/trueskill2.pdf
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
For instance
If you are in the top 1% - 5% of the game.
How often are you going to play with people at the same level as you. You aren't. Most of the time you will be playing with less skilled players, which is only going to increase your KDR.
Even if you have players as skilled as you in the server. Depending on the game play, you will still pick off all the usual players until you have to face off the same skilled player as yourself.
It seems to me the only time skill is actually tested is against tough opponents, ergo the KDR starts to stray AWAY from a skill assessment metric, since low skill players virtually walk right into your crosshairs (compared to a tougher opponent.)
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
Over 1.4k Golden Hawkeyes.
Yes, it definitely can. I'd still say though, that those folks on that KDR top list are still really good players, regardless of who they're playing against. The community is so kick/ban heavy, you can't possibly go 25-5 in servers for too long w/o getting banned in private servers.
But one thing i've found...especially in a FLO server..for every high skilled player, there are 8 other low skilled players to be killed. Definitely could still pull a 1.5+ in a FLO w/ good players. But BDX on the other hand, the odds of running into that high skilled player increase
Im just saying like Arkeiro said. If you are at the top of the food chain then your k/d is only going up. Doesnt matter how many other skilled players are in the server. You will pick off the easy ones until you have to engage with someone as skilled as you and then if you die, your k/d isnt going to change much. You've already killed all the bottom fraggers.
Some type of metric of KDR and damage would be where I would start for a toplist.
Yeah we are. There are a number of these services that natively integrate with UE4 that we would have to code by hand in UE3, and trueskill is one of them. Others, like Gamelift to manage server numbers and player backfill, will also be part of AAV.
Hopefully that's in a completely different game mode...dare I say, a competitive/ranked game mode. The queue times may be very long unless the playerbase is much larger than it is now.
Most certainly! As K/D ratio is a statistical representation used to measure how good you are ,the KDR or ADR (average Damage per Round as in csgo) also FPR (avg. Frags per round) is used to represent how useful you are for the team.
If you're interested in establishing skill rankings, you're gonna have to have some mathematical equation involving more than just one variable like KD.. the more complicated the more accurate.
#Support Comp Mode
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCN4YhM6jUB2MxVj8i3b9rhw
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
Whatever you do, you cannot outrun the devil.
Steam
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
Where is BCPULL when you need him
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
This has been a test of the emergency flame-fest system. Please do not adjust your set.
Still planned for the Top Players List is a search field so you can find specific players on the list.
We have also made some changes in the Player Stats page. The General Statistics section has been rearranged somewhat, and some new stats for Experience Points, Matches Lost, Match Win Percentage, Kills per Match, Points per Match, Points per Round, and Favorite Map have been added:
Since we received some negative feed back about the readability of the blue background and table cell borders we are trying out some alternative looks on the Player Stats page.
Are you able to get information on how much average damage someone does per round
The Toplist - Not the direction I would have gone but it is an option. For me I would think the Toplist would have some type of K/D and Damage ratio metric.
Top Kills - I would remove the unoffical leaderboard if you keep with the current format of Toplist because you can now sort
Remove takedowns as I dont think it is of importance
Remove Dev Kills - I dont see any value in parsing that info
Highest round score - I look at those numbers and I'm confused as to if that is match score or if it is really per round score.
Secures - I dont see the value in parsing that info
Favorite map - I dont know if I would say "favorite map", I would probably change that to "most Played map"
On a side note:
The player with a 5.71 K/D is either cheating or found a way to manipulate the info being parsed. The guy is averaging 16 kills a minute